New arson analysis may free convicted murderer - KXXV-TV News Channel 25 - Central Texas News and Weather for Waco, Temple, Killeen |

HEWITT

New arson analysis may free convicted murderer

Posted:

by Natasha Chen

HEWITT - New scientific developments in arson analysis may help set free a man convicted of capital murder more than 20 years ago.

Ed Graf was convicted of killing his two stepsons by burning them in a backyard shed in 1986. But the burn patterns on the floor that had given prosecutors reason to believe it was arson by gasoline, is now being revisited by scientists using newer knowledge of fires developed in the last two decades.

Attorney Walter Reaves and law students with the Baylor Innocence Project dug up the case and asked Dr. Gerald Hurst to re-examine the old evidence.

"Burns on the floor, holes in the floor, had been misinterpreted as being the accelerant poured like gasoline," said Dr. Hurst, "When in fact those patterns were caused by a phenomenon called flashover."

Flashover occurs when all combustible material in an enclosed area ignites almost simultaneously. Hurst said that objects in the shed, like the fold-up cot, could have brought the shed to the point of flashover in a matter of three minutes. Hurst even called the polyurethane foam in the mattress "solid gasoline."

But the original prosecutor, Vic Feazell, said that circumstantial evidence pointed strongly to Graf. "We had so much circumstantial evidence that I believe the jury would have convicted Ed Graf even without the arson evidence."

The circumstantial evidence he refers to is the fact that Graf did not feed the boys or fill their cereal boxes in the last days like he normally did, that he bought life insurance for them only months before the incident, and waited until the last minute to buy them new school clothes, all signs that the prosecutors said that meant Graf knew the boys would soon be gone.

In addition to evidence against Graf's character, original fire investigators also pointed to the burn patterns they thought were caused by gasoline, and the latch that had locked the boys in the shed. That physical evidence from the fire, however, is now being refuted by Hurst.

"In the period of the Graf case it was totally subjective," Hurst said in regard to the burn patterns. "But it was subject to a bunch of old wives' tales that people really believed in."

Don Youngblood, the original defense investigator, added, "It's been shown now that the assumptions made under the testimony by the fire experts was faulty, that the conclusions reached were not accurate."

Feazell however, holds to his belief that Graf is guilty. "I like it when people go back and look at old cases. I think it's what makes our criminal justice system great. Now I still think Ed Graf is guilty, but I think it's good they're looking at the case."

Reaves and the students with the Baylor Innocence Project are now attempting to get Graf a new hearing.

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • WACO

    Emotions run high during intense testimony in murder trial

    Emotions run high during intense testimony in murder trial

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 8:02 PM EDT2014-04-24 00:02:26 GMT
    Some hardball questioning by the prosecution during the sentencing phase of Carnell Petetan Jr. trial led to some near fireworks by the defense. Petetan, who faces the death penalty for murdering his wife, sat stoic for most of the day as witnesses came up to testify against him, but that all changed as his mother spoke Wednesday afternoon. After the prosecution rested just before 11 a.m., it was the defense's turn to call up witnesses. Petetan's attorney's stressed to the jury that they were...More >>
    Some hardball questioning by the prosecution during the sentencing phase of Carnell Petetan Jr. trial led to some near fireworks by the defense. Petetan, who faces the death penalty for murdering his wife, sat stoic for most of the day as witnesses came up to testify against him, but that all changed as his mother spoke Wednesday afternoon. After the prosecution rested just before 11 a.m., it was the defense's turn to call up witnesses. Petetan's attorney's stressed to the jury that they were...More >>
  • Political group formed to help pass Robinson ISD school bond

    Political group formed to help pass Robinson ISD school bond

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 6:50 PM EDT2014-04-23 22:50:48 GMT
    With the May elections just around the corner Robinson ISD's bond is back on the ballot. The district is seeking nearly $20 million to build a new intermediate to replace the 50 year-old building and make some repairs to the elementary school.More >>
    With the May elections just around the corner Robinson ISD's bond is back on the ballot. The district is seeking nearly $20 million to build a new intermediate to replace the 50 year-old building and make some repairs to the elementary school.More >>
  • WACO

    Police seized marijuana, arrest one after searching pickup

    Police seized marijuana, arrest one after searching pickup

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 3:56 PM EDT2014-04-23 19:56:53 GMT
    McGregor police arrested a man and seized $800 worth of marijuana as they served a search warrant on a pickup truck in the parking lot of a local billiard parlor Tuesday afternoon.More >>
    McGregor police arrested a man and seized $800 worth of marijuana as they served a search warrant on a pickup truck in the parking lot of a local billiard parlor Tuesday afternoon.More >>
Powered by WorldNow

News Channel 25 KXXV-TV
P.O. Box 2522
Waco, TX 76702

Phone Numbers:
Main: 254-754-2525
Tip Line: 254-757-2525

Links
Contact Us
KXXV Employment Opportunites
FCC Filings
Advertise on KXXV

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and KXXV. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.